IMG_2361
Blog powered by Typepad

« When worlds collide | Main | Healing hands »

Comments

"It's all in good fun, but viewers beware: in real life, neither mentalists nor mediums are as impressive as their Hollywood incarnations."

That may be true in most cases but sometimes mediums can be extraordinarily accurate in mental mediumship which no mentalist can emulate.

I am thinking, in particular, of people like Estelle Roberts, Helen Hughes and Gordon Higginson who were never less than brilliant in their demonstrations of mental mediumship.

Would that we had their like today.

I think especially some magigicians have the interest due to their own philosophy to regard every kind of psychic as fraud in public. I recently read a biography about Houdini from W Kalush / H Sloman (http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0743272072/ref=s9sdps_c3_14_at1-rfc_g1-frt_p-3215_g1-3102_p?pf_rd_m=ATVPDKIKX0DER&pf_rd_s=center-4&pf_rd_r=0JA3HPK9RKHG51GR93TD&pf_rd_t=101&pf_rd_p=436516201&pf_rd_i=507846). This was not a balanced analysis, but more a pamphlet against mediumship. Especially Margery was debunked in this book, supported by her living relative Anna Thurlow, who seems to have some original diary sheets from Margery. Mediumship is concluded here as a kind of criminal circle with a group of spiritual fanatics (here A C Doyle). The believe system of magicians is so different from open minded people, who can immagine that PK could be real. If people think that apports or other paranormal phenomena during a seance can never be real they have to believe that there MUST fraud.

I think I remember reading that Houdini was thrown off a Margery investigative team for trying to sneak in props to help him debunk Margery. He also accused Margery of fraud by finding one carpet thread on the floor. Also Houdini even designed the cabinet that Margery sit in and she still performed.

She would have had to fool lots of people for many years including two scientists from MIT that were able to take pictures of the thumb inside a locked box according to Harlow. Maybe later she started to lose her abilities and succumbed to fraud. One wrong thumb imprint of her dentist and not Walter’s out of over 100 does not prove her a fraud at least in my view.

People always claim to prove these mediums fraud after they have crossed over. One must remember like so many that get into mediumship or the investigation of mediums they start out to debunk mediums as Margery did because of her husbands new found interest in mediums after spending time with Lodge.

Someone named Dave from another blog sent me this website of someone who claims to know the validity of mediumship and spiritualism. I have learned with time that these so called debunkers are to be trusted very little if at all. Their intellectualism and cherished materialistic beliefs have overwhelmed their rational minds.

http://www.victorianweb.org/religion/spirit.html

The person that wrote this article believes everyone that believes in mediumship or anything paranormal is just demonstrating “sophisticated superstition.”

I can understand how these people have come to distrust anything that looks like religion. Today I attended a Christian church with a friend and the preacher stated. “Let god tell you how to vote, let god tell you how much to give each Sunday, and let god tell you how much to pledge for our new upgrades to the church. I.e. we need $300,000.00; I mean who can refuse god’s advice. :-)

William said: and let god tell you how much to pledge for our new upgrades to the church. I.e. we need $300,000.00; I mean who can refuse god’s advice. :-)
So tell the pastor "The devil told me to give you as much money as you want". Will he refuse it? I think not.

The believe system of magicians is so different from open minded people, who can immagine that PK could be real

Actually, many magicians and illusionists accept the paranormal as posssible or real, and even endorse it:

http://www.tricksterbook.com/ArticlesOnline/MagWhoEndors.htm

Problem is that many prominent skeptics/debunkers have been magicians (Houdini, Randi, Gardner, Wiseman, etc.), and they have spread the false notion that magicians are skeptics of the paranormal, because magicians "know" how to expose the psychics' tricks (that assumption tacitly implies that psi phenomena don't exist and are only tricks of conjurers). But surveys show that even most magicians are open to (or positively accept) some type of psi phenomena.

It's only another pseudo-skeptical myth to fool people and predispose the public against psi research.

I've read occasionally about a mentalist named the Amazing Dunnington (or something similar), a mentalist who performed regularly on the radio in the 40s and 50s in NYC. Could someone supply more information about him?

I think you may mean Dunninger:

Joseph Dunninger, the Master Mind whose mental wizardry has baffled scientists and psychologists throughout the world, is a native New Yorker, born just before the turn of the century and reared in the heart of the city.

But in Joseph there was awakened a yearning towards magic feats even at the age of five, when he showed a marked ability at sleight-of-hand. His parents encouraged this novelty; much amused they were at the dexterity in simple palming tricks. Self-taught, Dunninger soon had a remarkable repertoire of necromancy. His childhood pastime earned him an invitation to appear before a Masonic Club at the age of seven, where he was billed as "Master Joseph Dunninger, Child Magician."

It was at this time that he caused some wonderment among his schoolteachers. Master Joseph did not seem to be an extra brilliant pupil, but he invariably got all his arithmetic problems correct. Could it be that he copied the answers from bright children seated near him? His seating place in the classroom was frequently changed, but still Joseph's papers were marked 100%. Dunninger explains it now: "You see, I just couldn't get the wrong answer. I didn't have to work the problems out. The bright children in the classroom just sent me thought waves, and consequently I got everything right."

By the time that Dunninger was sixteen, he was an adult magician with an enviable reputation, and appeared for a year at the famous Eden Musee in 23rd Street. The boy Dunninger outmastered many of the most prominent prestidigitators of the day, and this launched him on a vaudeville tour. It was during this tour that he developed the astounding stunt of reading the minds of members of his audiences. For many years actors had presented such an illusion through the means of code messages between an assistant in the audience and the "thought reader" on stage. Dunninger used no assistants, and has never found it necessary to do so.

In fact, he has a standing offer of $10,000 to anyone who can prove that he uses confederates or "stooges". Dunninger often says he could raise that offer to $100,000. No one will ever collect it, because he does not need assistance.

Dunninger headlined throughout the Keith-Orpheum Circuit, and was much in demand for private entertainment. At the age of seventeen he was invited to perform at the home of Theodore Roosevelt in Oyster Bay and at the home of the inventor Thomas A. Edison, both of whom were avid admirers of his mysticism. It was during this association that Dunninger developed some of the remarkable experiments that he uses in his performance today.

His ability to read thoughts amazed the great Harry Houdini, and Howard Thurston went to great length in his search for the secret of Dunninger's mental wizardry. It was in this association that Dunninger took up his campaign of "illusion busting" waged against fraudulent mediums who have grown rich by falsification of séances that are designed to make people believe that word can come back from the spirit world.

Dunninger used no assistants. In an act of inspired marketing, Dunninger offered $10,000 to anyone who could prove that he uses stooges, confederates, or assistants of any kind. Dunninger said on many occasions that he could raise the offer to $100,000, because no one would ever collect it; he didn't need assistance to read thoughts. With such an act, and such a challenge, Dunninger was soon headlining the circuit and was very much in demand for private performances.

Through the Scientific American Magazine and the Universal Council for Psychic Research Dunninger has offered $10,000 to any medium who can produce by psychic or supernatural means any physical phenomena that he cannot reproduce by natural means or explain in convincing materialistic terms.

He has offered that amount of money to anyone who, with astral aid, can disclose the translation of secret code messages entrusted to him by the late Harry Houdini and Thomas A. Edison, both of whom wanted to investigate the possibilities of communication with spirits. Dunninger has also offered $10,000 to anyone who can introduce to him a real, house-hunting ghost. Needless to say, Dunninger never did pay out that money.

Most of the big-time vaudeville houses in the country boasted of having Dunninger on their stages in those days. Before long his "single" became a troupe of fifty, with "Dunninger, the Master Mind of Mental Mystery" presenting a full evening's entertainment which included all manner of amazing illusions. Many of the acts he created for the presence of many startling features in the repertoire of magicians now appearing before the public today. It is said that Dunninger has created more illusions than any other inventor of this type of entertainment now alive.

He has toured the world East and West, reading the thoughts of princes, Pope Pius XII, and had been invited to the White House six times for presidential parties at which times he read the minds of the presidents.

Time passed, and Dunninger became more and more in demand. Most of the largest vaudeville houses in the country hosted his shows. His act, with just himself performing, soon sported fifty performers, workers, and assistants. This new act, larger and more ponderous than anything he had done before, had Dunninger now presenting a full evening's entertainment, which now included several varieties of illusions. It was claimed at the time that Dunninger had invented more illusions and apparatus than anyone of that day.

Dunninger took the show to inspiring heights, performing all over the world. He read the thoughts of kings and princes, popes and presidents. But his fame would grow to astounding heights with the start of commercial radio.

When commercial radio started, Dunninger was the first paid entertainer to go on the air. His air debut was in a demonstration of hypnosis by radio. He was then heard in the role of a psychic detective, but neither of these features caught on. It was Daniel S. Tuthill, Vice-president and director of the Popular Division of the National Concert and Artists Corporation, who successfully evolved the Dunninger radio-formula--thought reading. The idea quickly caught the favor of Phillips Carlin, Vice-president of the Blue Network, and on September 12, 1943, Dunninger's first broadcast as Dunninger-the Master Mind was produced. Dunninger is now the sensation of the airwaves. Fan mail pours in, people clamor for tickets to the broadcast.

When television started proving itself to be a popular form of entertainment, Dunninger was there. He altered his act to fit the format of a television show. Amazingly, his series appeared on all the networks at different times. In the 1940s, a poll showed that his voice was more recognizable than that of the President's.
In addition to the radio shows and the television shows, Dunninger began appearing as a guest star on other popular shows. Because of his star-power, built on a foundation of popularity and associations with major stars of the time such as Lucille Ball and Milton Berle, he made appearances on Perry Como's radio shows and was a frequent guest on The Tonight Show with Steve Allen and Johnny Carson.
As brilliant as he was at performing, Dunninger proved a genius in marketing himself. To keep himself in the public eye, he wrote articles for magazines for both laymen and magicians. Soon the Dunninger by-line was carried in such popular magazines as Time, Life, Look, Reader's Digest, Vanity Fair, Science and Invention, True Detective, and Sphinx. Every article brought letters from readers, evoking more interest, and therefore more articles. And it all paid off. His books were bestsellers in weeks. He commanded huge sums for personal appearances. He packed theaters from coat to coast. At his peak, during the 1940s and 1950s, the public could not get enough of The Master Mind.

Dunninger performing style was unique to the day in that he typically sat on a stool or in a chair with nothing more than a pad of paper and a pencil. He would doodle while he called out names, initials, or numbers thought of by some member of his audience. When somebody identified the information as their own, Dunninger would spell out names, read social security numbers, or serial numbers from dollar bills. He would reveal word for word phrases merely written by a spectator. He usually concluded such a reading by asking, "Are you thinking of the word 'amazing'? Is it in reference to me? Thank you very much."

It's of note that Dunninger, perhaps because of his war against fraudulent mediums, never claimed supernatural or psychic powers in his thought-reading. He never even claimed to be a mind-reader. In performance, Dunninger referred to his ability as "telesthesia", an impression received by a sense organ, but not a usual sense organ, and sometimes received from a distance. He described the process simply: "You pick up a vivid impression from another mind and others follow or suggest themselves. But it isn't mind-reading; it is thought reading. When a series of such thought impressions come in fairly close in succession, it takes on the semblance of mind reading, though if you check back, you may find that you have added links of your own making, just as you might piece together the fragments of a dream to form a waking continuity."

Dunninger was a master of his craft, possessed of a thorough knowledge of his art. When describing the necessary techniques for a successful blindfold drive, Dunninger noted, "Any competent performer should know how to size up a committee and handle them accordingly. Otherwise he shouldn't be posing as a mentalist." While the extent of Dunninger's mental capabilities were always the subject of skeptical analysis, his capability to understand human reactions was beyond question. Dunninger operated on the assumption that people have a tendency to believe almost anything if they are so inclined. He was careful in the selection of participants in his tests and he employed a sort of mental misdirection; he suggested constraints on the tests he performed that seemed to prevent deception, but in reality allowed for it. He explained why one impromptu test worked so well: "I stressed as absolute precautions the very factors that were making the result possible."

Dunninger considered mentalists halfway between magicians and mediums. "Some mentalists," he said, "rely greatly on magical methods while others attempt actual tests in ESP. However far the pendulum swings, a capable mentalist will come through with results that a dyed-in-the-wool magician could never touch, because a mentalist plays hunches and realizes how often they may come through." And a mentalist doesn't have to advertise perfect results; Dunninger himself only claimed 90% accuracy.


Zerdini: Thanks for the info on Dunninger. Here are some follow-up questions.

Would D have passed Randi's test?

What was D's attitude toward parapsychologists like Rhine?

Did D ever submit to objective parapsychological tests, like Zener (sp?) cards, etc.?

What was the attitude of parapsychologists to D?

Did D disbelieve in anyone besides himself having psychic ability? It would seem so from the following two statements above:

"Through the Scientific American Magazine and the Universal Council for Psychic Research Dunninger has offered $10,000 to any medium who can produce by psychic or supernatural means any physical phenomena that he cannot reproduce by natural means or explain in convincing materialistic terms."

"Dunninger, perhaps because of his war against fraudulent mediums, never claimed supernatural or psychic powers in his thought-reading. He never even claimed to be a mind-reader. In performance, Dunninger referred to his ability as "telesthesia", an impression received by a sense organ, but not a usual sense organ, and sometimes received from a distance."

The latter seems like a distinction without a difference. It wounds to me like he was psychic, but waffled about it to fence-sit and avoid criticism from disbelievers.

Hi Roger

Dunninger who died in 1975 was a magician, escapologist and mentalist.

As far as I am aware he never claimed any psychic powers - he was simply an entertainer and probably one of the best of his time.

To Dunninger is attributed this quote:

Joseph Dunninger - Mentalist
- "For those who believe, no explanation is necessary. For those who do not, none will suffice."

Like the Piddingtons (the telepathic husband and wife team)in the UK no-one ever figured out how their act was done and neither has anyone equalled Dunninger.

For more information try contacting the magic fraternity in your area or try:

http://www.themagiccafe.com/forums/index.php
who may help you but magic secrets are very closely guarded.

“Dunninger has offered $10,000 to any medium who can produce by psychic or supernatural means any physical phenomena that he cannot reproduce by natural means or explain in convincing materialistic terms."

The words “explain in convincing materialistic terms”. There lies his out. You can bet the factory farm that it is Dunninger or people that he has selected that will determine what are convincing materialistic terms. People still fall for this stuff even a mag like Scientific American. Which gives you an idea of the mentality of the editors of such a magazine.

But if we put the name scientific in the title of our magazine many people think “oh they only deal with science and therefore facts”. It is called scientism and it is alive and well in a very materialistic world. As I had the “pleasure” of working with many scientists in the field of electronics with few exceptions these were from my point of view a very closed minded group of people.

It appears that advanced education can be as much a hindrance as a benefit. The human mind is an interesting phenomenon to say the least.

And some magician-skeptics use intellectual trickery to fool people into thinking no evidence exists for paranormal phenomena, while at the same time playing the role of heroic defender of reason and rationality.

One of their greatest tricks is to define "evidence" in such a way that the standard can always be raised beyond what a given phenomenon has produced, effectively diverting all past, present, and future evidence directly into the skeptic's trash can.

In case that Dunninger was correct how do we know the historic famous mediums like Piper or Mrs Leonard worked with ESP (also regarding the famous Book tests) and not with high intellectual suggestion?

The comments to this entry are closed.